We're sorry. An error has occurred
Please cancel or retry.
Dissentient Voice
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
Couldn't load pickup availability
-
April 15, 1982

In the seventeenth century, English religious Dissenters went to war with Cromwell and knocked the heads off stone saints; in the eighteenth, their heirs gathered quietly in chapel, sang hymns by Watts—and lived at once within the fold of dissenting protestant Christianity and the Age of Reason. It seems difficult to reconcile these aspects of Dissent, and especially to imagine that minds made facetious by thoughts of election and universal depravity should be armed by the expanisve, optimistic, and civil spirit of the Enlightenment.
But it is just this perceived incompatibility between Enlightenment and Dissent that Donald Davie seeks to reconcile in Dissentient Voice. Continuing the argument from his A Gathered Church (Oxford, 1978), Davie here contends that the members of the English dissentig hurches—Congregationalist, Baptist, Prebyterian, Quaker—were not, in the eighteenth century at least, the narrow-minded 'philistines' Matthew Arnold excoriated a century later. Rather, the tone Davie hears in the Dissenters' religious literature—most distinctly in the hums of Watts and Wesley—is one that combines passion and clarity, feeling and reason. The literature of Dissent is thus for Davie consonant with the Enlightenment.
"A collection of half a dozen related articles, only one of them previously unpublished, completes the volume, underlining Davie's interpretation of Dissent as a monolithic cultural entity embodying the classical strengths and virtues, in literature and politics as in religion. He attacks both the Anglican view of Dissent and that modern ignorance which assimilates it with secular left-wing protest." —The Evangelical Quarterly
"Donald Davie is the one major poet and critic of our time who really knows eighteenth century English poetry and intellectual history. Only those unwilling to rethink their preconceptions about English Dissent in that century—or about such later writers with a Dissenting background as Browing and Kipling—can afford to ignore this important book." —Donald Greene, University of Southern California
England's most acute literary critic has done us one more service. The easy equating of 'Dissent' with 'notions applauded today by all high-minded people' shouldn't any longer spare historians thought, nor serve to bemuse their readers. Required reading for anyone who dips in the Times Kiterary Supplement." —Hugh Kenner, Johns Hopkins University
Donald Davie's numerous critical works include studies of Scott, Hardy, and Pound. He has published ten collections of poetry, included Collected Poems, 1950-1970, and has edited The New Oxford Book of Christian Verse, which appeared in 1981.