"[Life and Religion at Louisbourg] serves as a model of what is possible to say about religious life in the eighteenth century. Combining study of fairly complete collections from French archives stored on microfilm at Louisbourg with first-hand access to archaeological evidence and a comprehensive grasp of the new wealth of historical material on popular religious life in eighteenth-century France, Johnston describes the religious practices and attitudes of the three religious orders and the common folk of the town. Lively where anecdotal material appears, thorough where statistical evidence is relevant and careful where it would be unwarranted to speculate, Johnston enlightens the reader and simultaneously points the way to further research." Tom Sinclair-Faulkner, Studies in Religion.
"[Life and Religion at Louisbourg] adds significantly to our knowledge of the colony ... Johnston presents as clear and complete a picture of what happened to his Louisbourg subjects as we are likely to get." Richard Place, The Eighteenth Century.
"A comprehensive and helpful examination ... of an untypical and isolated community." Patricia Birkett, Archivaria.
"A pleasant book, accessible to the honest reader ... No one will doubt the interest and value of Life and Religion at Louisbourg whether for the history of Catholicism in North America or for that of the Atlantic region." Pierre Trépanier, Canadian Historical Review.