We're sorry. An error has occurred
Please cancel or retry.
Outsourced Children
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
Couldn't load pickup availability
-
31 August 2016
It's no secret that tens of thousands of Chinese children have been adopted by American parents and that Western aid organizations have invested in helping orphans in China—but why have Chinese authorities allowed this exchange, and what does it reveal about processes of globalization?
Countries that allow their vulnerable children to be cared for by outsiders are typically viewed as weaker global players. However, Leslie K. Wang argues that China has turned this notion on its head by outsourcing the care of its unwanted children to attract foreign resources and secure closer ties with Western nations. She demonstrates the two main ways that this "outsourced intimacy" operates as an ongoing transnational exchange: first, through the exportation of mostly healthy girls into Western homes via adoption, and second, through the subsequent importation of first-world actors, resources, and practices into orphanages to care for the mostly special needs youth left behind.
Outsourced Children reveals the different care standards offered in Chinese state-run orphanages that were aided by Western humanitarian organizations. Wang explains how such transnational partnerships place marginalized children squarely at the intersection of public and private spheres, state and civil society, and local and global agendas. While Western societies view childhood as an innocent time, unaffected by politics, this book explores how children both symbolize and influence national futures.
— Nazli Kibria
"Outsourced Children is a provocative analysis of the global assemblages of care around children in Chinese orphanages. Drawing on a deep well of original fieldwork, Wang bring to life the ideologies, economic inequalities, and gendered and raced imaginaries that swirl around children at the intersections of 'soft power' and 'outsourced intimacy.'"
— Sara Dorow
"Wang's compelling ethnography shows how state agendas, market imperatives, and conflicting visions of childcare held by Western do-gooders and Chinese caregivers create a transnational market in special needs children that serves different agendas. A caringly crafted, unsettling, yet humane account of how the one-child policy continues to remake our world."
— Susan Greenhalgh
"Wang's vivid and accessible writing, and her ability to raise difficult issues about the best interests of children in local, national, and transnational contexts makes Outsourced Children a compelling read for undergraduate and graduate students, policymakers, and general readers. "
— Catherine Ceniza Choy
"A reflexive approach Wang employs in the presentation of her ethnographic study definitely plays a significant role in this book. Readers are able to understand how the author's analyses have come about through the discussion of her own identities and subjectivity, which is a methodological strength of the book. Compelling parts of Outsourced Children include Wang's analysis of a particular type of globalization process in which children are the integral part of the PRC's movement toward modernization as well as how the children serve an important role in Westerners' desire to participate prominently in international humanitarianism."
— Kazuyo Kubo
The introduction gives a broad overview of the book and locates the circulation of children across families, institutions, and nations within the larger context of the PRC's rapid global rise. Socio-economic transitions and the increasingly competitive nature of Chinese society marginalized offspring who are considered to lack future economic potential. I draw attention to children's experiences within state-run institutions that received aid from international humanitarian NGOs and the ensuing conflicts over their care. This book explains how and why Chinese authorities have permitted Western groups to use their own resources to care for marginalized children in light of China's changing relationship with the industrialized world.
This chapter orients readers to the societal causes and consequences of child abandonment in the reform era, a time of unprecedented economic growth. As the Chinese government encourages parents to bear "high quality" offspring for the sake of the nation, many rural daughters and special needs children have been relinquished to state care. This chapter explores how growing economic insecurity, stringent fertility regulations, and cultural preferences for sons have devalued millions of healthy girls and special needs children.
Untold numbers of abandoned "missing girls" languished in state-run orphanages until 1992, when the Chinese government first began its international adoption program. Since then over 130,000 children have joined families across a wide range of countries in the global north. This chapter argues that foreign demand has transformed gender into an advantage as girls have been transformed into priceless Western daughters. The chapter explores the racialized and gendered reasons why these girls are so highly sought after and discusses how this desire has stimulated an underground market in babies. As China has become increasingly influential globally, the number of healthy adoptable girls has declined. Moreover, in recent years, the Chinese government has severely limited the eligibility of Western parents while encouraging domestic placements. These shifts in adoption trends therefore also demonstrate China's growing ability to assert itself on the global stage using the symbolic value of its children.
The global humanitarian aid industry's presence in China has allowed government authorities to outsource intimate labor to highly resourced foreign groups, which are motivated by their own child-saving agendas. This chapter draws from fieldwork conducted in the Tomorrow's Children infant palliative care unit. Thus unit, which was housed within the grounds of Chinese state orphanages, were funded and managed by middle-class evangelical Christian volunteers. Volunteers employed first-world medical practices and universalistic ideologies regarding children's best interests to care for the orphanages' children. This chapter examines conflicts that erupted between Westerners and the local working-class Chinese caregivers who were expected to implement the imported practices. This case shows that children's "best interests" are not universal, but are instead shaped by the surrounding context and access to resources. Moreover, the involvement of Western institutions in Chinese orphanages can actually create stratification between children in terms of their opportunities.
This chapter highlights the collaboration between the Helping Hands organization, a group comprised of Western expatriate women volunteers, and the Yongping Orphanage located outside of Beijing. This chapter argues that the elite gendered space occupied by the volunteers led them to develop a logic of care based solely in maternal nurturance. This logic permeated their volunteer efforts, causing conflicts with Chinese state caregivers who prioritized the performance of reproductive tasks such as cleaning and laundry. These two irreconcilable logics of care caused recurring friction and ambivalence on both sides. Thus, the tensions involved in this transnational care collaboration illustrate the complexity of global humanitarian efforts in non-Western contexts.
Although most scholarly attention has centered on healthy female adoptees, in recent years a growing number of special needs children have been placed in foreign homes. This chapter draws on fieldwork in Tomorrow's Children special care units to highlight efforts taking place in China to transform unwanted disabled children into internationally desirable daughters and sons. In the special care units, processes of outsourced intimacy remade marginalized youth into first-world citizens who were prepared for middle-class lives abroad. This chapter also highlight the role that American Christian evangelicals have played in popularizing an "adoption movement" that seeks to promote U.S. moral authority around the world through the adoption of individual children.
The final chapter discusses the larger implications of this study. It reviews the argument and considers the extent to which the Chinese government's outsourcing of intimacy to global humanitarian organizations and actors has impacted the lives of institutionalized children. The chapter returns to the author's two main ethnographic fieldsites and discusses the implications of outsourced intimacy on new waves of Chinese adoptees who are making the decision to return to China as tourists or to attempt to locate their birth parents. The concluding section explores the significance of child abandonment, orphanage care, and transnational adoption in terms of China's continuing fraught relationship with the industrialized world.