We're sorry. An error has occurred
Please cancel or retry.
Overseen or Overlooked?
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
Couldn't load pickup availability
-
23 September 2025

"War is too important to be left to the generals," declared French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau over a century ago. But which civilians, exactly, play the most important roles in controlling the armed forces? When civilian control is studied, the focus is typically on those in the upper echelons of the executive branch: presidents, prime ministers, or defense secretaries. Yet, because civilians in the executive may be tempted to hide problems or use the military in controversial ways, researchers must extend Clemenceau's dictum: if war is too important to be left to the generals, civilian control is too important to leave with the executive. This book aims to understand the similarities and differences among the world's democracies regarding the role of legislatures in democratic civil-military relations. Drawing on over a dozen cases from across the globe, the authors examine how most legislatures face capability and motivational impediments to conducting truly robust oversight and propose realistic reforms to strengthen military accountability to elected officials and the public—the heart of the civil-military relationship.
Two. Explaining Legislative Oversight Over the Armed Forces
I. ARE WESTMINSTER PARLIAMENTS IGNORANT AND IRRELEVANT?
Three. Westminster in the Atlantic: The United Kingdom and Canada
Four. Westminster in the Pacific: Australia,New Zealand, and Japan
II. CONSENSUAL DEMOCRACIES
Five. Consensual Democracies in the Heart of Europe: Germany and Belgium
Six. Consensual Democracies in the High North: Finland, Norway, and Sweden
III. CONGRESSES ARE OVERRATED
Seven. Not All Congresses: Brazil, Chile, and South Korea
Eight. Older Presidential Systems: France and the United States
Nine. Conclusion: Comparisons, Implications, and Lessons